Where we last left off, they had just announced the Final Fantasy VII Remake. And before I get into the long wait that followed, I think it makes sense, at this point, to talk about my skepticism (and my hopes) around ever seeing a Final Fantasy of that scale made with modern graphics.
Because in 2015, if you'd been paying attention, there were reasons to doubt.
The Golden Age
The way I see it, the golden age of Final Fantasy was that first PlayStation era. Final Fantasy VII, VIII, and IX all had that grand scale. Now, they were built very differently from a modern game. Locked camera angles, two-dimensional pre-rendered backdrops with three-dimensional characters walking around on top of them, cutting away to pre-rendered scenes for the big moments. That was the formula. And inside that formula, the worlds felt enormous.
Final Fantasy VIII was just as big as VII, if not bigger. It got a mixed reception. The Junction system confused a lot of people, there was an unfortunate bit of writing regarding mass amnesia, but I think the biggest issue it faced was that it just wasn't FF7. All that said, I enjoyed it quite a bit. Among other things, it introduced Triple Triad, which is, to my taste, one of the best mini-games in the entire series.
Final Fantasy IX was another very large game. Lots of travel, lots to discover. You even get a flying chocobo and a secret boss in the sky. I'll admit it wasn't my cup of tea right away. Coming off FFVII and FFVIII, where your characters were basically blank slates (you picked your party on preference and then built their abilities however you wanted via Materia or Junctioning respectively) I wasn't fond of everyone being locked into their battle roles. In FFIX you built your party around abilities (classes, if you will) instead of building abilities around your party. That's something I've actually come to appreciate since, now that I'm more familiar with games that have class/job systems. But at the time, it felt constricting.
Point being: three games, three huge worlds. World maps. Airships. Secrets in every corner. That was what Final Fantasy meant to me.
The Turn
Then you get to Final Fantasy X.
FFX was the first big move into voice acting and actual 3D environments, and I want to be fair to it: it didn't strike me at the time that nearly every area in the game was a corridor. It genuinely didn't. It still felt like there was freedom in there. But one moment did strike me, and it stuck: the moment you get the airship. Because it wasn't an airship. There was no overworld to fly over. You just picked a point on a map. That was the beginning of fast travel, and it was not what I was looking for. There was maybe one properly open stretch in the whole game (maybe two, it's been a minute since I've been there) but everything still felt like Final Fantasy.
There were towns. There were people. There was Blitzball. Hold that thought.
The Ones I Skipped
Final Fantasy XI I never even touched. It was an MMO. I had no interest in paying a subscription, no interest in being online. I wanted the on-console experience. So as far as I was concerned, that number just didn't happen.
I skipped X-2 as well. It seemed superfluous, and (If I'm being honest about where my head was at back then) it looked like it was aimed at an audience that wasn't me. Maybe it deserved a fairer shake. It didn't get one from me.
Final Fantasy XII
That made Final Fantasy XII my next real entry, and credit where it's due: that one had some scale to it. Still no overworld. You walked from zone to zone, and yes, there were airships, though as I remember it, they worked about like FFX's did. But the zones were big, and there were a lot of them.
It still wasn't my cup of tea. It had a decent story; the problem was that your main character (Vaan) was pretty much pointless in it. Looking back now, the whole thing feels like it was borrowing from MMO design they'd built for FFXI. The battles already felt like an MMO. And the idea that your protagonist is basically along for the ride, witnessing a story that belongs to other people? That's very much how it felt when I eventually dipped a toe into FFXIV, years later.
The Corridor Simulator
Final Fantasy XIII is where it really fell apart for me. And understand that I had followed every mainline Final Fantasy up to this point, the online ones aside.
When FFXIII was announced, they actually announced two games at once (three, technically, but the mobile one never crossed my radar) Final Fantasy XIII and Final Fantasy Versus XIII. I watched trailers for both, and honestly? Versus looked more interesting than FFXIII itself. But I wasn't going to Pass on FFXIII. It was the first HD entry on the seemingly powerful PS3.
When I played it, it became obvious pretty quickly that something was missing. People took to calling it a corridor simulator, and that's about right: nothing but linear travel, the entire game, until you reach one big open area near the end: Gran Pulse. One big open area, with hours and hours of corridors on either side of it.
It just didn't feel like Final Fantasy. Its defenders liked to point out that it was structured a lot like X (which is largely true). Except X had towns, people, interactions, and mini-games. Blitzball was great. FFXIII just felt empty. It told a decent little story, but it didn't really end. Probably because they intended it to be a Trilogy. They later released FFXIII-2 and eventually Lightning Returns. I never played either one. The first game wasn't good enough to keep me interested.
Meanwhile,
Final Fantasy XIV was, again, an online game, so again, not what I wanted out of a Final Fantasy. But even watching from the outside, you couldn't miss what happened to it: the original version launched in 2010 in such rough shape that Square Enix ended up publicly apologizing for it, taking the whole thing offline, and rebuilding it from scratch. Their flagship online game was so broken they had to un-release it. Not exactly a confidence builder. (I did get around to it years later. By then it was the rebuilt version, A Realm Reborn, which was reportedly a much better game than what had initially shipped. It wasn't bad. I just don't have that kind of time to sink into a game anymore.)
But as you may have noticed, something is missing from this timeline: Versus XIII never came out. The game that looked more interesting than FFXIII back in 2006 simply never materialized. Eventually it got re-announced as Final Fantasy XV, and some of what they showed did look cool. It looked larger in scale than the FFXIII games anyway. But it had everything left to prove. And knowing where it started, that game had been in the making for what, nine years at that point? Nine years, and the game wasn't in the hands of the players...
That Brings Us Back To 2015
So that's the scoreboard I was staring at when they announced the Final Fantasy VII Remake.
The last mainline Final Fantasy with a true world map had shipped in 2000. The airship had been a menu ever since. The flagship of the HD era was, to put it kindly, a corridor with one field in the middle. And the one game that had promised old-school ambition with modern technology had spent nine years as a ghost and had yet to be released.
And still, I felt a glimmer of hope. Maybe we could get a large-scale Final Fantasy again. Maybe, of all things, this Final Fantasy VII Remake would be the one to pull it off.
But what if they couldn't? Were they going to have to pare it all down, make it a smaller experience just so they could fit in the cutscenes and the nostalgia? And how long was it going to be before I actually saw this game? Development times had gotten enormous, and I wasn't the kid at Fry's anymore. I was an adult. Married. A kid of my own on the way. Some part of me did the math on all of that and didn't love the answer.
They'd announced the remake. Now they had to prove they still remembered how to build a world.
